Share your Hallmark store experience, and see what others had to say.
Choose one of these review sites:
Your feedback helps make Hallmark stores even better. Thank you!
Store Locations:New York:East Islip:Amy's Hallmark Shop

Amy's Hallmark Shop | East Islip, NY

Find a store

Use current location
Amy's Hallmark Shop
East Islip Shopping Center
2650 Sunrise Hwy Unit 2
East Islip, NY 11730-1000
Write a review
Monday-Saturday
10:00 am - 9:00 pm
Sunday
10:00 am - 5:00 pm
Same-day pickup
Nearby Locations
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      0.0
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      East Islip Shopping Center
      2650 Sunrise Hwy Unit 2
      East Islip, NY 11730-1000
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      4.2
      MILES
      Lemarc's Hallmark Shop
      Gardiner Manor Mall
      830 Sunrise Hwy
      Bay Shore, NY 11706-5908
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      9.1
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Smith Haven Mall
      648 Smith Haven Mall
      Lake Grove, NY 11755-1250
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      11.1
      MILES
      Lynne's Hallmark
      Expressway Plaza
      2324 N Ocean Ave
      Farmingville, NY 11738-2909
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      11.5
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Airport Plaza
      203 Airport Plaza Blvd
      Farmingdale, NY 11735-3934
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      11.5
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      12.4
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Walt Whitman Shops
      160 Walt Whitman Rd Ste 1084
      Huntington Station, NY 11746-4132
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      12.7
      MILES
      Mari's Hallmark Store
      395 Fort Salonga Rd Ste A
      Northport, NY 11768-3099
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      14.3
      MILES
      Setauket Cards & Gifts
      West Shopping Center
      242 Route 25A
      Setauket, NY 11733-2853
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      17.3
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Broadway Commons
      358 Broadway Mall Ste 212
      Hicksville, NY 11801-2709
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      25.4
      MILES
      Celebrations Cards
      11 Atlantic Ave
      Lynbrook, NY 11563-3007
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      25.6
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      28.9
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Stamford
      Ridgeway Shopping Center
      2321 Summer St
      Stamford, CT 06905-4525
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      28.9
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      30.5
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Fairfield
      Black Rock Shopping Center
      2255 Black Rock Tpke
      Fairfield, CT 06825-3243
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      31.0
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Norwalk
      Walmart Center
      652 Main Ave Ste 1
      Norwalk, CT 06851-1182
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      31.8
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Stratford
      Stratford Square
      411 Barnum Ave Cutoff Ste 9
      Stratford, CT 06614-5100
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      32.0
      MILES
      Celebrations Cards
      Whitestone Shopping Center
      15375 Cross Island Pkwy
      Whitestone, NY 11357-2648
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      33.7
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Westfield Trumbull
      5065 Main St # 1122
      Trumbull, CT 06611-4217
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      34.6
      MILES
      Haven Card Shop
      8603 Jamaica Ave
      Woodhaven, NY 11421-2043
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      36.1
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Milford
      Milford Marketplace
      1660 Boston Post Rd
      Milford, CT 06460-2776
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      36.3
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Shelton Square Shopping Center
      870 Bridgeport Ave
      Shelton, CT 06484-4625
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      36.8
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Yonkers Gateway Center
      2482 Central Park Ave
      Yonkers, NY 10710-1125
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      39.3
      MILES
      Lisa's On 2Nd Avenue
      1751 2Nd Ave Frnt 3
      New York, NY 10128-5393
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      40.3
      MILES
      Amreen's Hallmark Shop
      820 2Nd Ave Frnt 1
      New York, NY 10017-4512
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      41.3
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      41.4
      MILES
      Jay's Hallmark Shop
      625 8Th Ave Ste 201
      New York, NY 10018-2733
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      41.6
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Branford
      Branhaven Plaza
      1060 W Main St
      Branford, CT 06405-3441
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      41.8
      MILES
      Rose's Hallmark Shop
      Reservoir Plaza
      425 Anderson Ave
      Fairview, NJ 07022-1103
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      42.4
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      7 Hanover Sq Frnt B
      New York, NY 10004-4012
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      42.9
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      45.7
      MILES
      Country Card Corner
      Klarides Village
      7 Klarides Village Dr
      Seymour, CT 06483-2737
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      46.3
      MILES
      Barry's Hallmark Shop
      Danbury Fair
      7 Backus Ave Ste 274
      Danbury, CT 06810-7495
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      46.5
      MILES
      Nikki's Card Shop
      60 W Pleasant Ave
      Maywood, NJ 07607-1338
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      47.1
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Westwood Plaza
      700 Broadway Ste 60
      Westwood, NJ 07675-1674
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      47.4
      MILES
      Rose's Hallmark Shop
      South Cove Plaza
      2 Lefante Dr
      Bayonne, NJ 07002-5021
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      47.6
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      48.3
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of North Haven
      North Haven Shopping Center
      57 Washington Ave
      North Haven, CT 06473-1704
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      49.2
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Brookfield
      Candlewood Lake Plaza
      14 Candlewood Lake Rd Ste 4
      Brookfield, CT 06804-2529
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      49.4
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Clifton
      Clifton Commons
      110 Kingsland Rd
      Clifton, NJ 07014-1915
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      49.5
      MILES
      Gift & Card Gallery
      Clarkstown Plaza
      232 S Main St
      New City, NY 10956-3318

Amy's Hallmark Shop in East Islip Shopping Center is here for all of your gift, ornament and card needs!

With a broad selection of year-round and seasonal gifts, Keepsake Ornaments and greeting cards, Amy's Hallmark Shop located in East Islip, NY is the perfect store for all of your special occasions. Our gift and card shop has something to help you celebrate any special occasion, holiday or even ordinary day!

Celebrate Holidays with Hallmark

This gift shop’s selection includes cards and gifts for holidays including but not limited to:

  • • Valentine’s Day
  • • Easter
  • • Mother’s Day
  • • Father’s Day
  • • The 4th of July
  • • Halloween
  • • Thanksgiving
  • • Christmas
  • • Hanukkah
  • • New Year’s
  • • And More

Hallmark Helps You Show You Care

Let our kind, courteous staff help you celebrate life events large and small or show you care in moments of need. We’re proud to offer a wide selection of gifts and cards for important moments such as:

  • • Birthdays
  • • Baby Showers
  • • Baptisms
  • • First Communions
  • • Confirmations
  • • Get Well
  • • Graduations
  • • New Babies
  • • Sympathy
  • • Wedding and Bridal Showers
  • • And More

When you need to send support and encouragement, we offer a selection of thinking-of-you, get well and sympathy cards. With Hallmark Gold Crown’s variety of products, including home decor, picture frames, photo albums, accessories, stationery, Christmas ornaments, candles, candy, books, gift wrap, stuffed animals and more, we have gifts for kids and adults alike. Product selection and availability varies throughout the year, so stop by today and check out what’s in store for you at Amy's Hallmark Shop. For questions, call us at (631) 859-5240.

You can also shop online anytime at Hallmark.com. Same-day in-store pickup is also available – just order online and choose Amy's Hallmark Shop at 2650 Sunrise Hwy Unit 2 to pick up your items in a matter of hours.

Nearby Locations
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      0.0
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      East Islip Shopping Center
      2650 Sunrise Hwy Unit 2
      East Islip, NY 11730-1000
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      4.2
      MILES
      Lemarc's Hallmark Shop
      Gardiner Manor Mall
      830 Sunrise Hwy
      Bay Shore, NY 11706-5908
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      9.1
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Smith Haven Mall
      648 Smith Haven Mall
      Lake Grove, NY 11755-1250
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      11.1
      MILES
      Lynne's Hallmark
      Expressway Plaza
      2324 N Ocean Ave
      Farmingville, NY 11738-2909
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      11.5
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Airport Plaza
      203 Airport Plaza Blvd
      Farmingdale, NY 11735-3934
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      11.5
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      12.4
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Walt Whitman Shops
      160 Walt Whitman Rd Ste 1084
      Huntington Station, NY 11746-4132
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      12.7
      MILES
      Mari's Hallmark Store
      395 Fort Salonga Rd Ste A
      Northport, NY 11768-3099
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      14.3
      MILES
      Setauket Cards & Gifts
      West Shopping Center
      242 Route 25A
      Setauket, NY 11733-2853
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      17.3
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Broadway Commons
      358 Broadway Mall Ste 212
      Hicksville, NY 11801-2709
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      25.4
      MILES
      Celebrations Cards
      11 Atlantic Ave
      Lynbrook, NY 11563-3007
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      25.6
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      28.9
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Stamford
      Ridgeway Shopping Center
      2321 Summer St
      Stamford, CT 06905-4525
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      28.9
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      30.5
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Fairfield
      Black Rock Shopping Center
      2255 Black Rock Tpke
      Fairfield, CT 06825-3243
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      31.0
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Norwalk
      Walmart Center
      652 Main Ave Ste 1
      Norwalk, CT 06851-1182
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      31.8
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Stratford
      Stratford Square
      411 Barnum Ave Cutoff Ste 9
      Stratford, CT 06614-5100
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      32.0
      MILES
      Celebrations Cards
      Whitestone Shopping Center
      15375 Cross Island Pkwy
      Whitestone, NY 11357-2648
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      33.7
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Westfield Trumbull
      5065 Main St # 1122
      Trumbull, CT 06611-4217
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      34.6
      MILES
      Haven Card Shop
      8603 Jamaica Ave
      Woodhaven, NY 11421-2043
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      36.1
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Milford
      Milford Marketplace
      1660 Boston Post Rd
      Milford, CT 06460-2776
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      36.3
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Shelton Square Shopping Center
      870 Bridgeport Ave
      Shelton, CT 06484-4625
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      36.8
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Yonkers Gateway Center
      2482 Central Park Ave
      Yonkers, NY 10710-1125
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      39.3
      MILES
      Lisa's On 2Nd Avenue
      1751 2Nd Ave Frnt 3
      New York, NY 10128-5393
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      40.3
      MILES
      Amreen's Hallmark Shop
      820 2Nd Ave Frnt 1
      New York, NY 10017-4512
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      41.3
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      41.4
      MILES
      Jay's Hallmark Shop
      625 8Th Ave Ste 201
      New York, NY 10018-2733
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      41.6
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Branford
      Branhaven Plaza
      1060 W Main St
      Branford, CT 06405-3441
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      41.8
      MILES
      Rose's Hallmark Shop
      Reservoir Plaza
      425 Anderson Ave
      Fairview, NJ 07022-1103
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      42.4
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      7 Hanover Sq Frnt B
      New York, NY 10004-4012
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      42.9
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      45.7
      MILES
      Country Card Corner
      Klarides Village
      7 Klarides Village Dr
      Seymour, CT 06483-2737
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      46.3
      MILES
      Barry's Hallmark Shop
      Danbury Fair
      7 Backus Ave Ste 274
      Danbury, CT 06810-7495
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      46.5
      MILES
      Nikki's Card Shop
      60 W Pleasant Ave
      Maywood, NJ 07607-1338
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      47.1
      MILES
      Amy's Hallmark Shop
      Westwood Plaza
      700 Broadway Ste 60
      Westwood, NJ 07675-1674
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      47.4
      MILES
      Rose's Hallmark Shop
      South Cove Plaza
      2 Lefante Dr
      Bayonne, NJ 07002-5021
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      47.6
      MILES
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      48.3
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of North Haven
      North Haven Shopping Center
      57 Washington Ave
      North Haven, CT 06473-1704
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      49.2
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Brookfield
      Candlewood Lake Plaza
      14 Candlewood Lake Rd Ste 4
      Brookfield, CT 06804-2529
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      49.4
      MILES
      The Paper Store Of Clifton
      Clifton Commons
      110 Kingsland Rd
      Clifton, NJ 07014-1915
      • Gold Crown Store YES
      49.5
      MILES
      Gift & Card Gallery
      Clarkstown Plaza
      232 S Main St
      New City, NY 10956-3318