Share your Hallmark store experience, and see what others had to say.
Choose one of these review sites:
Your feedback helps make Hallmark stores even better. Thank you!
Store Locations:New York:Amherst:The Paper Store Holiday Cards & Decorations

The Paper Store & Gift Store

Find a store

Use current location
The Paper Store
Boulevard Consumer Square
1569 Niagara Falls Blvd Ste 3A
Amherst, NY 14228-2704
Free store pickup
  • In-store shopping
  • Curbside pickup
Write a review

Store Hours

Friday
10:00 am - 8:00 pm
Saturday
10:00 am - 8:00 pm
Sunday
10:00 am - 6:00 pm
Monday
10:00 am - 8:00 pm
Tuesday
10:00 am - 8:00 pm
Wednesday
10:00 am - 8:00 pm
Thursday Closed
Nearby Locations
  • 2.9
    MILES
    Jo-An's Hallmark Shoppe
    3600 Delaware Ave
    Buffalo, NY 14217-1108
    • In-store shopping
    • In-store shopping
    • Curbside pickup
    • Curbside pickup
  • 12.2
    MILES
    Annie's Hallmark Shop
    Southgate Plaza
    1046 Union Rd
    West Seneca, NY 14224-3449
    • In-store shopping
    • In-store shopping
    • Curbside pickup
    • Curbside pickup
  • 14.4
    MILES
    Spalding Ace Hardware
    215 Davison Rd
    Lockport, NY 14094-3330
    • In-store shopping
    • In-store shopping
    • Curbside pickup
    • Curbside pickup

The Paper Store in Boulevard Consumer Square is here for all of your gift, ornament and card needs!

With a broad selection of year-round and seasonal gifts, Keepsake Ornaments and Hallmark product, The Paper Store located in Amherst, NY is the perfect store for all of your special occasions. Our gift and card shop has something to help you celebrate any special occasion, holiday or even ordinary day!

Celebrate Holidays with Hallmark

This gift shop’s selection includes cards and gifts for holidays including but not limited to:

  • • Valentine’s Day
  • • Easter
  • • Mother’s Day
  • • Father’s Day
  • • The 4th of July
  • • Halloween
  • • Thanksgiving
  • • Christmas
  • • Hanukkah
  • • New Year’s
  • • And More


Hallmark Helps You Show You Care

Let our kind, courteous staff help you celebrate life events large and small or show you care in moments of need. We’re proud to offer a wide selection of gifts and cards for important moments such as:

  • • Birthdays
  • • Baby Showers
  • • Baptisms
  • • First Communions
  • • Confirmations
  • • Get Well
  • • Graduations
  • • New Babies
  • • Sympathy
  • • Wedding and Bridal Showers
  • • And More


When you need to send support and encouragement, we offer a selection of thinking-of-you, get well and sympathy cards. With Hallmark Gold Crown’s variety of products, including home decor, picture frames, photo albums, accessories, stationery, Christmas ornaments, candles, candy, books, gift wrap, stuffed animals and more, we have gifts for kids and adults alike. Product selection and availability varies throughout the year, so stop by today and check out what’s in store for you at The Paper Store. For questions, call us at (716) 835-9739.

You can also shop online anytime at ThePaperStore.com. Same-day in-store pickup is also available – just order online and choose The Paper Store at 1569 Niagara Falls Blvd Ste 3A to pick up your items in a matter of hours.

Nearby Locations
  • 2.9
    MILES
    Jo-An's Hallmark Shoppe
    3600 Delaware Ave
    Buffalo, NY 14217-1108
    • In-store shopping
    • In-store shopping
    • Curbside pickup
    • Curbside pickup
  • 12.2
    MILES
    Annie's Hallmark Shop
    Southgate Plaza
    1046 Union Rd
    West Seneca, NY 14224-3449
    • In-store shopping
    • In-store shopping
    • Curbside pickup
    • Curbside pickup
  • 14.4
    MILES
    Spalding Ace Hardware
    215 Davison Rd
    Lockport, NY 14094-3330
    • In-store shopping
    • In-store shopping
    • Curbside pickup
    • Curbside pickup