Share your Hallmark store experience, and see what others had to say.
Choose one of these review sites:
Your feedback helps make Hallmark stores even better. Thank you!
Store Locations:New York:Setauket:Setauket Cards & Gifts

Setauket Cards & Gifts | Setauket, NY

Find a store

Use current location
Setauket Cards & Gifts
West Shopping Center
242 Route 25A
Setauket, NY 11733-2853
Write a review
Thursday Holiday Hours Closed
Friday
9:00 am - 8:00 pm
Saturday
9:00 am - 8:00 pm
Sunday
9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Monday
9:00 am - 8:00 pm
Tuesday
9:00 am - 8:00 pm
Wednesday
9:00 am - 8:00 pm
Nearby Locations
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    0.0
    MILES
    Setauket Cards & Gifts
    West Shopping Center
    242 Route 25A
    Setauket, NY 11733-2853
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    4.1
    MILES
    Lemarc's Hallmark Shop
    Mt Sinai Shopping Center
    5507 Nesconset Hwy Ste 25
    Mount Sinai, NY 11766-2019
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    5.2
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Smith Haven Mall
    648 Smith Haven Mall
    Lake Grove, NY 11755-1250
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    8.9
    MILES
    Lynne's Hallmark
    Expressway Plaza
    2324 N Ocean Ave
    Farmingville, NY 11738-2909
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    12.5
    MILES
    Mari's Hallmark Store
    395 Fort Salonga Rd Ste A
    Northport, NY 11768-3099
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    14.3
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    East Islip Shopping Center
    2650 Sunrise Hwy Unit 2
    East Islip, NY 11730-1000
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    16.9
    MILES
    Lemarc's Hallmark Shop
    Gardiner Manor Mall
    830 Sunrise Hwy
    Bay Shore, NY 11706-5908
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    17.7
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Walt Whitman Shops
    160 Walt Whitman Rd Ste 1084
    Huntington Station, NY 11746-4132
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    18.0
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Stratford
    Stratford Square
    411 Barnum Ave Cutoff Ste 9
    Stratford, CT 06614-5100
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    18.5
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Fairfield
    Black Rock Shopping Center
    2255 Black Rock Tpke
    Fairfield, CT 06825-3243
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    21.0
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Connecticut Post Mall
    1201 Boston Post Rd Ste 2051A
    Milford, CT 06460-2786
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    21.0
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Westfield Trumbull
    5065 Main St # 1122
    Trumbull, CT 06611-4217
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    21.2
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Airport Plaza
    203 Airport Plaza Blvd
    Farmingdale, NY 11735-3934
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    21.9
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Milford
    Milford Marketplace
    1660 Boston Post Rd
    Milford, CT 06460-2776
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    22.2
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Norwalk
    Walmart Center
    652 Main Ave Ste 1
    Norwalk, CT 06851-1182
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    22.7
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Shelton Square Shopping Center
    870 Bridgeport Ave
    Shelton, CT 06484-4625
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    23.9
    MILES
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    24.5
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Stamford
    Ridgeway Shopping Center
    2321 Summer St
    Stamford, CT 06905-4525
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    24.7
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Broadway Mall
    358 Broadway Mall Ste 212
    Hicksville, NY 11801-2709
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    27.4
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Branford
    Branhaven Plaza
    1060 W Main St
    Branford, CT 06405-3441
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    31.2
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Sand Hill Plaza
    228 S Main St Ste C8
    Newtown, CT 06470-2700
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    31.4
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Hamden Plaza
    2100 Dixwell Ave Ste 8
    Hamden, CT 06514-2406
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    31.8
    MILES
    Country Card Corner
    Klarides Village
    7 Klarides Village Dr
    Seymour, CT 06483-2737
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    33.9
    MILES
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    34.0
    MILES
    Cricket's Hallmark Shop
    North Haven Shopping Center
    57 Washington Ave
    North Haven, CT 06473-1704
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    35.2
    MILES
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    35.2
    MILES
    Celebrations Cards
    11 Atlantic Ave
    Lynbrook, NY 11563-3007
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    36.0
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Danbury Fair
    7 Backus Ave Ste 274
    Danbury, CT 06810-7495
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    37.6
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Yonkers Gateway Center
    2482 Central Park Ave
    Yonkers, NY 10710-1125
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    37.8
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Southbury Plaza
    100 Main St N Unit 9
    Southbury, CT 06488-3840
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    37.8
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Brookfield
    Candlewood Lake Plaza
    14 Candlewood Lake Rd Ste 4
    Brookfield, CT 06804-2529
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    37.9
    MILES
    Celebrations Cards
    Whitestone Shopping Center
    15375 Cross Island Pkwy
    Whitestone, NY 11357-2648
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    40.5
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Wallingford Fair Shopping Center
    850B N Colony Rd
    Wallingford, CT 06492-2410
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    42.4
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Brass Mill Center
    495 Union St Ste 2086
    Waterbury, CT 06706-3202
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    42.7
    MILES
    Haven Card Shop
    8603 Jamaica Ave
    Woodhaven, NY 11421-2043
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.1
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Jefferson Valley Mall
    650 Lee Blvd Ste F15
    Yorktown Heights, NY 10598-1155
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.2
    MILES
    Lisa's On 2Nd Avenue
    1751 2Nd Ave Frnt 3
    New York, NY 10128-5393
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.2
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Westfield Meriden
    470 Lewis Ave Ste 78
    Meriden, CT 06451-2111
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.2
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    New Milford Plaza
    172 Danbury Rd
    New Milford, CT 06776-4328
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.4
    MILES
    Kay's Hallmark Shop
    Old Saybrook Shopping Center
    665 Boston Post Rd Ste 2
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475-1524
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.7
    MILES
    Bouton's Hallmark Shop
    Palisades Center Mall
    3660 Palisades Center Dr Ste C302
    West Nyack, NY 10994-6612
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    46.8
    MILES
    Rose's Hallmark Shop
    Reservoir Plaza
    425 Anderson Ave
    Fairview, NJ 07022-1103
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    46.8
    MILES
    Amreen's Hallmark Shop
    820 2Nd Ave Frnt 1
    New York, NY 10017-4512
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    47.7
    MILES
    Jay's Hallmark Shop
    625 8Th Ave Ste 201
    New York, NY 10018-2733
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    48.0
    MILES
    Gift & Card Gallery
    Clarkstown Plaza
    232 S Main St
    New City, NY 10956-3318
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    48.4
    MILES
    Towne Apothecary
    95 Main St S
    Bethlehem, CT 06751-2004
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    48.5
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Westwood Plaza
    700 Broadway Ste 60
    Westwood, NJ 07675-1674
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    49.7
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    7 Hanover Sq Frnt B
    New York, NY 10004-4012
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    49.8
    MILES
    Nikki's Card Shop
    60 W Pleasant Ave
    Maywood, NJ 07607-1338

Setauket Cards & Gifts is here for all of your gift, ornament and card needs!

With a broad selection of year-round and seasonal gifts and greeting cards, Setauket Cards & Gifts located at 242 Route 25A in Setauket, NY is the perfect store for all of your special occasions. Our selection includes cards and gifts for annual events and holidays like birthdays, anniversaries, Valentine's Day, Easter, Mother's Day, Father's Day, the 4th of July, Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Hanukkah, New Year's, and more! Let us help you celebrate major life events, as well. We're proud to offer gifts, cards and more for baby showers, baptisms, First Communions, confirmations, graduations, wedding showers and beyond. When you need to send support and encouragement, we offer a selection of thinking-of-you, get well and sympathy cards. With our variety of products, including home decor, picture frames, photo albums, apparel, accessories, jewelry, stationery, collectibles, Christmas ornaments, candles, candy, books, gift wrap, stuffed animals and kitchen goods, we have gifts for kids and adults alike.

Setauket Cards & Gifts is your holiday shopping destination for great stocking stuffers and games the whole family will enjoy! Product selection and availability varies throughout the year, so stop by today and check out what's in store for you at Setauket Cards & Gifts.
Nearby Locations
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    0.0
    MILES
    Setauket Cards & Gifts
    West Shopping Center
    242 Route 25A
    Setauket, NY 11733-2853
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    4.1
    MILES
    Lemarc's Hallmark Shop
    Mt Sinai Shopping Center
    5507 Nesconset Hwy Ste 25
    Mount Sinai, NY 11766-2019
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    5.2
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Smith Haven Mall
    648 Smith Haven Mall
    Lake Grove, NY 11755-1250
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    8.9
    MILES
    Lynne's Hallmark
    Expressway Plaza
    2324 N Ocean Ave
    Farmingville, NY 11738-2909
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    12.5
    MILES
    Mari's Hallmark Store
    395 Fort Salonga Rd Ste A
    Northport, NY 11768-3099
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    14.3
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    East Islip Shopping Center
    2650 Sunrise Hwy Unit 2
    East Islip, NY 11730-1000
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    16.9
    MILES
    Lemarc's Hallmark Shop
    Gardiner Manor Mall
    830 Sunrise Hwy
    Bay Shore, NY 11706-5908
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    17.7
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Walt Whitman Shops
    160 Walt Whitman Rd Ste 1084
    Huntington Station, NY 11746-4132
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    18.0
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Stratford
    Stratford Square
    411 Barnum Ave Cutoff Ste 9
    Stratford, CT 06614-5100
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    18.5
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Fairfield
    Black Rock Shopping Center
    2255 Black Rock Tpke
    Fairfield, CT 06825-3243
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    21.0
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Connecticut Post Mall
    1201 Boston Post Rd Ste 2051A
    Milford, CT 06460-2786
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    21.0
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Westfield Trumbull
    5065 Main St # 1122
    Trumbull, CT 06611-4217
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    21.2
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Airport Plaza
    203 Airport Plaza Blvd
    Farmingdale, NY 11735-3934
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    21.9
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Milford
    Milford Marketplace
    1660 Boston Post Rd
    Milford, CT 06460-2776
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    22.2
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Norwalk
    Walmart Center
    652 Main Ave Ste 1
    Norwalk, CT 06851-1182
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    22.7
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Shelton Square Shopping Center
    870 Bridgeport Ave
    Shelton, CT 06484-4625
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    23.9
    MILES
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    24.5
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Stamford
    Ridgeway Shopping Center
    2321 Summer St
    Stamford, CT 06905-4525
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    24.7
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Broadway Mall
    358 Broadway Mall Ste 212
    Hicksville, NY 11801-2709
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    27.4
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Branford
    Branhaven Plaza
    1060 W Main St
    Branford, CT 06405-3441
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    31.2
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Sand Hill Plaza
    228 S Main St Ste C8
    Newtown, CT 06470-2700
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    31.4
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Hamden Plaza
    2100 Dixwell Ave Ste 8
    Hamden, CT 06514-2406
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    31.8
    MILES
    Country Card Corner
    Klarides Village
    7 Klarides Village Dr
    Seymour, CT 06483-2737
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    33.9
    MILES
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    34.0
    MILES
    Cricket's Hallmark Shop
    North Haven Shopping Center
    57 Washington Ave
    North Haven, CT 06473-1704
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    35.2
    MILES
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    35.2
    MILES
    Celebrations Cards
    11 Atlantic Ave
    Lynbrook, NY 11563-3007
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    36.0
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Danbury Fair
    7 Backus Ave Ste 274
    Danbury, CT 06810-7495
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    37.6
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Yonkers Gateway Center
    2482 Central Park Ave
    Yonkers, NY 10710-1125
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    37.8
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Southbury Plaza
    100 Main St N Unit 9
    Southbury, CT 06488-3840
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    37.8
    MILES
    The Paper Store Of Brookfield
    Candlewood Lake Plaza
    14 Candlewood Lake Rd Ste 4
    Brookfield, CT 06804-2529
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    37.9
    MILES
    Celebrations Cards
    Whitestone Shopping Center
    15375 Cross Island Pkwy
    Whitestone, NY 11357-2648
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    40.5
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Wallingford Fair Shopping Center
    850B N Colony Rd
    Wallingford, CT 06492-2410
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    42.4
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    Brass Mill Center
    495 Union St Ste 2086
    Waterbury, CT 06706-3202
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    42.7
    MILES
    Haven Card Shop
    8603 Jamaica Ave
    Woodhaven, NY 11421-2043
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.1
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Jefferson Valley Mall
    650 Lee Blvd Ste F15
    Yorktown Heights, NY 10598-1155
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.2
    MILES
    Lisa's On 2Nd Avenue
    1751 2Nd Ave Frnt 3
    New York, NY 10128-5393
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.2
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Westfield Meriden
    470 Lewis Ave Ste 78
    Meriden, CT 06451-2111
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.2
    MILES
    Barry's Hallmark Shop
    New Milford Plaza
    172 Danbury Rd
    New Milford, CT 06776-4328
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.4
    MILES
    Kay's Hallmark Shop
    Old Saybrook Shopping Center
    665 Boston Post Rd Ste 2
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475-1524
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    45.7
    MILES
    Bouton's Hallmark Shop
    Palisades Center Mall
    3660 Palisades Center Dr Ste C302
    West Nyack, NY 10994-6612
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    46.8
    MILES
    Rose's Hallmark Shop
    Reservoir Plaza
    425 Anderson Ave
    Fairview, NJ 07022-1103
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    46.8
    MILES
    Amreen's Hallmark Shop
    820 2Nd Ave Frnt 1
    New York, NY 10017-4512
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    47.7
    MILES
    Jay's Hallmark Shop
    625 8Th Ave Ste 201
    New York, NY 10018-2733
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    48.0
    MILES
    Gift & Card Gallery
    Clarkstown Plaza
    232 S Main St
    New City, NY 10956-3318
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    48.4
    MILES
    Towne Apothecary
    95 Main St S
    Bethlehem, CT 06751-2004
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    48.5
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    Westwood Plaza
    700 Broadway Ste 60
    Westwood, NJ 07675-1674
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    49.7
    MILES
    Amy's Hallmark Shop
    7 Hanover Sq Frnt B
    New York, NY 10004-4012
    • Gold Crown Store YES
    49.8
    MILES
    Nikki's Card Shop
    60 W Pleasant Ave
    Maywood, NJ 07607-1338